Retired — 1986s
| Player | Pos | Previous club | Years here |
|---|---|---|---|
| Charlie Davies | ST | — | — |
| Chris Tierney | CM | — | — |
| Corey Ashe | CB | — | — |
| Eddie Gaven | CM | — | — |
| Edgar Castillo | CB | — | — |
| Graham Zusi | CM | — | — |
| Jonathan Spector | CB | — | — |
| Lee Nguyen | CM | — | — |
| Marvell Wynne | CB | — | — |
| Maurice Edu | CM | — | — |
| Quentin Westberg | GK | — | — |
| Sam Cronin | CM | — | — |
| Shea Salinas | CM | — | — |
| Steve Clark | GK | — | — |
| Steven Lenhart | ST | — | — |
| Tim Melia | GK | — | — |