The 2000s
| Player | Pos | Club | NT callups |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aboubacar Keita | CB | Kalmar FF | 0 |
| Alessandro Castro | CM | Atlético Buford FC | 0 |
| Alex Mendez | CM | El Paso Locomotive FC | 0 |
| Allexon Saravia | CB | Inter Santa Tecla | 0 |
| Andrew Carleton | CM | — | 0 |
| Andrés Perea | CM | New York City FC | 0 |
| Ayo Akinola | ST | — | 0 |
| Ben Lederman | CM | Wieczysta Kraków | 0 |
| Benji Kikanovic | ST | San Jose Earthquakes | 0 |
| Brenden Aaronson | CM | Leeds United | 0 |
| CJ dos Santos | GK | San Diego FC | 0 |
| Chris Durkin | CM | St. Louis CITY SC | 0 |
| Chris Gloster | CB | New Mexico United | 0 |
| Chris Richards | CB | Crystal Palace | 0 |
| Daryl Dike | ST | Orlando City SC | 0 |
| Dylan Teves | CM | Snohomish United | 0 |
| Edwin Cerrillo | CM | LA Galaxy | 0 |
| Frankie Amaya | CM | CF Montréal | 0 |
| George Acosta | CM | — | 0 |
| Isaac Angking | CM | — | 0 |
| Isaiah Parente | CM | LA Galaxy | 0 |
| Jacobo Reyes | — | Tepatitlán | 0 |
| James Sands | CM | New York City FC | 0 |
| Jaylin Lindsey | CB | — | 0 |
| Jeremy Rafanello | ST | Philadelphia Union | 0 |
| Jesús Ferreira | ST | Seattle Sounders FC | 0 |
| Jorge Hernandez | CM | San Antonio FC | 0 |
| Josh Sargent | ST | Toronto FC | 0 |
| Justin Garces | GK | — | 0 |
| Kipp Keller | CM | New Mexico United | 0 |
| Michael Edwards | CB | Oakland Roots SC | 0 |
| Nicholas Gioacchini | ST | — | 0 |
| Patrick Agyemang | ST | Derby County | 0 |
| Richard Ledezma | CM | Chivas | 0 |
| Roman Celentano | GK | FC Cincinnati | 0 |
| Sean Zawadzki | CM | Columbus Crew | 0 |
| Sebastian Soto | ST | Retired | 0 |
| Sergiño Dest | RB | PSV Eindhoven | 0 |
| Timothy Weah | ST | Marseille | 0 |
| Will Sands | CB | New England Revolution | 0 |
| Zico Bailey | CB | New Mexico United | 0 |
| Zyen Jones | CM | — | 0 |